Difference between revisions of "Criticism of Mormonism/Books/One Nation Under Gods/Use of sources/Brigham Says to "Cut Their Throats""

(link)
m (→‎top: Bot replace {{FairMormon}} with {{Main Page}} and remove extra lines around {{Header}})
 
(33 intermediate revisions by 7 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
−
__NOTOC__
+
{{Main Page}}
−
{{FAIRAnalysisHeader
+
{{H1
−
|title=[[../../]]
+
|L=Criticism of Mormonism/Books/One Nation Under Gods/Use of sources/Brigham Says to "Cut Their Throats"
−
|author=Richard Abanes
+
|H=Brigham says to "Cut Their Throats"
−
|noauthor=
+
|S=
−
|section=[[../../Use of sources|Use of sources]], Brigham Says to "Cut Their Throats"
+
|L1=
−
|previous=[[../Early federal territorial officials|Early federal territorial officials]]
+
|T=[[../../|One Nation Under Gods]]
−
|next=[[../Orders to Starve Gentiles|Orders to Starve Gentiles]]
+
|A=Richard Abanes
−
|notes={{AuthorsDisclaimer}}
+
|<=[[../Brigham and bowie knife|Brigham and the bowie knife - Threatening apostates?]]
 +
|>=[[../Orders to Starve Gentiles|Orders to Starve Gentiles]]
 
}}
 
}}
−
=Brigham Says to "Cut Their Throats"=
+
{{Author claims label}}
−
==The Quote==
+
 
 
===''One Nation under Gods'', page 236-237 (hardback)===
 
===''One Nation under Gods'', page 236-237 (hardback)===
−
Apostates certainly were viewed as the worst of sinners, although every reprobate received the same penalty. As Brigham instructed his flock: "If any miserable scoundrels come here, cut their throats.53
+
Apostates certainly were viewed as the worst of sinners, '''although every reprobate received the same penalty. As Brigham instructed his flock''': "If any miserable scoundrels come here, cut their throats."53 {{ea}}
  
 
===''One Nation under Gods'', page 236-237 (paperback)===
 
===''One Nation under Gods'', page 236-237 (paperback)===
−
Apostates certainly were viewed as the worst sinners, although every reprobate, risked similar justice. Young once said: "It was asked this mormong how we could obtain redress for our wrongs; I will tell you how it could be done, we could take the same law they have taken...and if any miserable scoundrels come here, cut their throats."55
+
Apostates certainly were viewed as the worst sinners, '''although every reprobate, risked similar justice. Young once said''': "It was asked this morning how we could obtain redress for our wrongs; I will tell you how it could be done, we could take the same law they have taken...and if any miserable scoundrels come here, cut their throats."55 {{ea}}
  
−
==The Reference==
+
{{Author sources label}}
−
===Endnote 53, page 563 (hardback)===
 
−
{{JDwiki|author=Brigham Young|url=http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Journal_of_Discourses/Volume_2/The_Kingdom_of_God|vol=2|pages=311}}.
 
  
−
==The Problems==
+
===Endnote 53, page 563 (hardback); page 561 (paperback)===
−
In an effort to forward his agenda of depicting Brigham in a negative light, the author lifts a couple of sentence fragments from one of Young's statements and leaves the context behind. Here is the more complete quote from that discourse, in context (the portion the author quotes is in bold):
+
{{JDfairwiki|author=Brigham Young|disc=47|vol=2|start=311}}.
  
−
<blockquote>
+
{{:Question: Did Brigham Young advocate that apostates have their throats cut?}}
−
'''It was asked this morning how we could obtain redress for our wrongs; I will tell you how it could be done, we could take the same law they have taken''', viz., mobocracy, '''and if any miserable scoundrels come here, cut their throats.''' (All the people said, Amen.) This would be rooting out that treatment to wicked men, which they had measured to innocent persons. We could meet them on their own ground, when they will not honor the law, but will kill the Prophets and destroy the innocent. They could drive the innocent from their homes, take their houses and farms, cattle and goods, and destroy men, women, and children, walking over the laws of the United States, trampling them under their feet, and not honoring a single law. Suppose I should follow the example they have shown us, and say, "Latter-day Saints, do ye likewise, and bid defiance to the whole clan of such men?
+
</onlyinclude>
−
</blockquote>
+
{{endnotes sources}}
 +
{{SeeAlso|Blood_atonement#Brigham_Young.27s_preaching_style|l1=Brigham Young's preaching style}}
  
−
So, was Brigham "instructing?" No! When the matter was put before him, regarding what should be done to those who had come and robbed, murdered and destroyed (he had just been asked that morning), Brigham said "here's how we COULD approach it," so to speak. "Suppose I should follow the example they have shown us," he says. "I will tell you how it COULD be done." These are not instructions, by any means. You have ripped the statement from its context and presented it as instructions to kill the Church's enemies, when that is not what Brigham said.
 
  
−
If one were to say, in writing a review of an anti-Mormon book written by a Southern Baptist, "Suppose I write a book against the Baptists? I have been asked what to do about the horrible attacks on our Church from the Southern Baptists. I will tell you how it could be done, we could start writing anti-Baptist books and attack their history, their origins and their leaders. Suppose I were to follow the example they have set?" Would one be correct in making the statement that Cooper Johnson said that Mormons should, "start writing anti-Baptist books and attack their history?" Certainly not.
 
  
−
It is a supposition for the purposes of making a point. Nowhere in this statement of Brigham's is he advocating the cutting of anyone's throat.
 
  
−
=Further reading=
+
[[Category:Brigham Young]]
−
{{AbanesWorks}}
 

Latest revision as of 13:15, 13 April 2024

Brigham says to "Cut Their Throats"



Brigham and the bowie knife - Threatening apostates?
A FAIR Analysis of: One Nation Under Gods, a work by author: Richard Abanes
 		Orders to Starve Gentiles

Author's Claims


One Nation under Gods, page 236-237 (hardback)

Apostates certainly were viewed as the worst of sinners, although every reprobate received the same penalty. As Brigham instructed his flock: "If any miserable scoundrels come here, cut their throats."53 (emphasis added)

One Nation under Gods, page 236-237 (paperback)

Apostates certainly were viewed as the worst sinners, although every reprobate, risked similar justice. Young once said: "It was asked this morning how we could obtain redress for our wrongs; I will tell you how it could be done, we could take the same law they have taken...and if any miserable scoundrels come here, cut their throats."55 (emphasis added)

Author's Sources


Endnote 53, page 563 (hardback); page 561 (paperback)

Brigham Young, Journal of Discourses 2:311..


Question: Did Brigham Young advocate that apostates have their throats cut?

Nowhere in this statement of Brigham's is he advocating the cutting of anyone's throat

The book One Nation Under Gods claims that "Apostates certainly were viewed as the worst sinners, although every reprobate, risked similar justice. Young once said: 'It was asked this morning how we could obtain redress for our wrongs; I will tell you how it could be done, we could take the same law they have taken...and if any miserable scoundrels come here, cut their throats.'" [1]

We note that the paperback corrects the erroneous statement that Brigham "instructed" people to "cut their throats." Here is the more complete quote from Brigham's discourse, in context (the portion ONUG quotes is in bold):

It was asked this morning how we could obtain redress for our wrongs; I will tell you how it could be done, we could take the same law they have taken, viz., mobocracy, and if any miserable scoundrels come here, cut their throats. (All the people said, Amen.) This would be rooting out that treatment to wicked men, which they had measured to innocent persons. We could meet them on their own ground, when they will not honor the law, but will kill the Prophets and destroy the innocent. They could drive the innocent from their homes, take their houses and farms, cattle and goods, and destroy men, women, and children, walking over the laws of the United States, trampling them under their feet, and not honoring a single law. Suppose I should follow the example they have shown us, and say, "Latter-day Saints, do ye likewise, and bid defiance to the whole clan of such men?"

So, was Brigham giving instructions? No! When the matter was put before him, regarding what should be done to those who had come and robbed, murdered and destroyed (he had just been asked that morning), Brigham said "here's how we COULD approach it," so to speak. "Suppose I should follow the example they have shown us," he says. "I will tell you how it COULD be done." These were not instructions, by any means. Nowhere in this statement of Brigham's is he advocating the cutting of anyone's throat.


Notes

  1. ↑ Richard Abanes, One Nation Under Gods, Endnote 53, page 563 (hardback); page 561 (paperback).
See also: Brigham Young's preaching style
Retrieved from "https://www.fairlatterdaysaints.org/answers/index.php?title=Criticism_of_Mormonism/Books/One_Nation_Under_Gods/Use_of_sources/Brigham_Says_to_%22Cut_Their_Throats%22&oldid=236934"