| Page
|
Claim
|
Response
|
Author's sources
|
402 (PB)
|
The Mormon Tabernacle Choir "has been one of the most effective tools of evangelism used by Latter-day Saints to proselytize unsuspecting music lovers..."
|
|
|
403
|
"[T]he general public, especially outside America, still possesses little knowledge of the unsavory nature of Mormonism."
|
|
|
403, 605n9
|
Baptisms for the dead were performed for "various Nazis, including Adolf Hitler, whom Mormons sealed for eternity to his mistress, Eva Braun. It was apparently done in order to give Hitler and his henchmen an opportunity to accept Mormonism in the afterlife and thereby become gods."
|
- Members of the Church leave all judgment in God's hands. They are commanded to perform vicarious ordinances for all deceased persons for whom records exist. This is no way guarantees or implies Hitler's acceptance of Mormonism or forgiveness. Such matters are left to God.
- Does the author really wish to imply, though, that even the most wicked sinner might be beyond the reach of Christ's atoning grace? The Latter-day Saints do not.
- Baptism for the dead
- Loaded and prejudicial language
|
- Helen Radkey, "The Mormon Church Attempts to Conceal Temple Records for Adolf Hitler"
- Jan Cienski, "Jews Urge Mormons to Curb Zeal," National Post, June 6, 2001.
|
403
|
Baptisms for the dead are "a non-Christian practice."
|
- The author's claim is false: the Bible itself describes Christians carrying out this practice: 1 Corinthians 15:29.
- It may not be a practice found in the author's brand of Christianity, but it has ample precedent among early believers.
- Hugh W. Nibley, "Baptism for the Dead in Ancient Times," Improvement Era (1948, 1949), multiple. off-site
- Baptism for the dead
|
|
404
|
"It is possible that many readers of this book have had their deceased relatives baptized by proxy into Mormonism, even though such persons might not have wanted anything to do with Mormonism during their lives."
|
|
|
| Page
|
Claim
|
Response
|
Author's sources
|
404, 605n14
|
"Mormons took it upon themselves to baptize...Jews who had perished in Nazi concentration camps."
|
|
- Bob Mims, "LDS Try to End Unauthorized Work for Jews," Salt Lake Tribune, May 2, 2001.
|
405, 605n18-19
|
LDS leaders "actively suppress the activities of would-be researchers in Mormon archives."
|
- Steven L. Olsen, "Is the Church Archives Closed?" (FAIR Conference, 2007). FAIR link
- The author fails to note that Fawn Brodie worked in the 1940s, when the archives were less well-organized—her experience is irrelevant to the present-day.
- Censorship_and_revision_of_LDS_history
|
- Fawn Brodie. Quoted by Newell G. Bringhurst, "Fawn McKay Brodie: Dissident Historian and Quintessential Critic of Mormondom," in Roger Launius, Linda Thatcher, Leonard J. Arrington, eds., Differing Visions: Dissenters in Mormon History, 290.
- B. Carmon Hardy, "Truth and Mistruth in Mormon History," in Lavina Fielding Anderson and Janice Merrill Allred, eds., Case Reports of the Mormon Alliance, vol. 3, 279. (The author lists all three volumes as "available for purchase" from the Tanner's ULM.)
|
405, 605n21
|
"LDS leaders re-write historical documents, deny that other documents exist, create fictitious historical data, add words to update old revelations so that they conform to current events/knowledge, and delete various sections of divine pronouncements said to have been transcribe perfectly when originally delivered."
|
|
|
406, n22
|
The History of the Church was "supposedly written by Joseph Smith" but was mostly written after his death.
|
- This is no secret; using Joseph's authorial voice was standard practice for the day.
- The history was completed up to 5 August 1838 under Joseph's direction (See Jesse, 466).
- Authorship of History of the Church
|
- Dean C. Jessee, "The Writing of Joseph Smith's History," Brigham Young University Studies [Summer 1971], vol. 11, 469, 470, 472.
- Jerald and Sandra Tanner, Mormonism—Shadow or Reality?, 5th edition, (Salt Lake City: Utah Lighthouse Ministry, 1987), 126-162D.
- Jerald and Sandra Tanner, The Changing World of Mormonism (Moody Press, 1979), 398-416.( Index of claims )
- Jerald and Sandra Tanner, Major Problems of Mormonism.
|
406
|
Changing the history so that it "read as if Joseph Smith himself had written the material...was a flagrant breach of standard protocol for persons producing historical works."
|
- The author's claim is false: using Joseph's authorial voice was standard practice for the day.
- The Jesse article cited above by the author demonstrates that no effort was made to hide who had written the history.
- Authorship of History of the Church
- Presentism
|
|
406, 606n23
|
One of the "forged predictions" added to the history was that of a "mighty people" that would dwell "in the midst of the Rocky Mountains."
|
|
- History of the Church, vol. 5, 85, 393-394, 398.
- No other citation is given to support this claim, but the argument is found in Jerald and Sandra Tanner, The Changing World of Mormonism (Moody Press, 1979), [ATTENTION!].([[The Changing World of Mormonism/Index [ATTENTION!]| Index of claims ]])
|
406, 606n23
|
One of the "forged predictions" added to the history was "about the political career of Senator Steven A. Douglas." [check spelling] - Should be "Stephen"
|
- The author's claim is false: in fact, the prediction was published more than a year before Douglas' attack on the Church; this was well-before his aspirations to the U.S. presidency or fall in political fortunes.
- Timing of Stephen A. Douglas prophecy [ATTENTION!]
|
- History of the Church, vol. 5, 85, 393-394, 398.
- No other citation is given to support this claim.
|
407, 606n26
|
"[M]ore than 62,000 words were either added or deleted" from the history. The endnote adds that "Mormon leaders additionally claim that their official history is not only 'an unusually accurate historical document,' but is 'the most accurate history in all the world'"
|
|
- John Widtsoe, Joseph Smith-Seeker After Truth, 297.
- Joseph Fielding Smith, Doctrines of Salvation, vol. 2, 199.
|
407
|
Volume six of the History of the Church "contains the minutes from Smith's October 1843 church conference regarding Sidney Rigdon....But when compared to the minutes originally printed in the Times and Seasons....the revised/modern version reveals an account exactly opposite of what actually happened."
|
|
- History of the Church, vol. 6, 47-48.
- Times and Seasons, vol. 4, 330.
|
408, 608n28 (HB) 606n28 (PB)
|
"Another tactic utilized by Mormon leaders has been to revise Smith's revelations so as to make the church's history more palatable."
|
|
- Hugh Nibley, letter to Morris L. Reynolds, May 12, 1966. Quoted in Jerald Tanner and Sandra Tanner, Case Against Mormonism (Salt Lake City: ULM, 1967), vol. 1, 132.
|
408, 607n33 (PB)
|
"LDS officials in the early 1960s" attempted to "suppress a copy of the Book of Commandments locked in their church archives."
|
|
- Tanner and Tanner, Major Problems of Mormonism, 135.
|
| Page
|
Claim
|
Response
|
Author's sources
|
412
|
"Most of the academic dishonesty foisted upon church members by LDS scholars and leaders relates to the Mormon notion that all works of history must be 'faith-promoting.'"
|
|
|
412
|
"Mormonism has been an emotion-based religion opposed to intellectual, rational thought."
|
- Many Mormons seem to have been able to use "intellectual, rational thought" to demonstrate the many errors, distortions, and misstatements in this work attacking their faith.
- LDS testimonies involve both mind and heart.
- Members of the Church become more active and committed to their faith as their degree of education increases: Education and belief. This does not prove the Church true, but it does put the lie to claims that members are ill-informed, uneducated, or ignorant.
- Loaded and prejudicial language
|
|
412
|
Latter-day Saints are supposed to only rely on the "burning in the bosom" even "when faced with irrefutable facts that undermine the LDS church."
|
|
|
412, 607n34
|
Latter-day Saints are instructed to "simply not think and obey church authorities." The endnote states: "The message has never been rescinded in any official way."
|
|
- "Ward Teachers Message," Deseret News, May 26, 1945, 5.
- Improvement Era, June 1945, 354.
|
413-414, 609-610n39 (HB)
|
"Some of the most disturbing instructions about blind obedience came from LDS president Ezra Taft Benson in his 'Fourteen Fundamentals in Following the Prophet' speech. His fundamentals for living a righteous Mormon life left little room for independent thought."
|
|
- Ezra Taft Benson, "Fourteen Fundamentals in Following the Prophet," February 26, 1980.
|
| Page
|
Claim
|
Response
|
Author's sources
|
414, 608n42 (PB)
|
Quoting Steven Benson: "When the prophet has spoken, the debate is over."
|
- The author's claim is false: This claim was made once in a church magazine, and the president of the Church immediately declared it to be false. Anti-Mormons continue to invoke it.
- When the Prophet speaks, the thinking is done? (non-wiki)
|
- Steve Benson, 60 Minutes, April 7, 1996.
|
415, 608-609n43-57 (PB)
|
The Church excommunicated a number of "perceived dissidents."
|
|
- Jerald and Sandra Tanner, "Mormon Inquisition?" LDS Leaders Move to Repress Rebellion," Salt Lake City Messenger (#85), November 1993.
- Lavina Fielding Anderson, "The LDS Intellectual Community and Church Leadership: A Contemporary Chronology," Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought (Spring 1993), vol. 26.
- Paul Toscano, "All Is Not Well in Zion: Falsoe Teachings of the True Church" (1993), Sunstone Symposium lecture.
- Maxine Hanks, Women and Authority: Re-emerging Mormon Feminism.
- D. Michael Quinn, "On Being a Mormon Historian (and Its Aftermath)," in George D. Smith, Faithful History: Essays On Writing Mormon History, 76 (endnote #22 in Quinn).
- Boyd K. Packer, "The Mantle Is Far, Far Greater Than the Intellect", August, 22, 1981.
- Boyd K. Packer, Let Not Your Heart Be Troubled, 106.
- Boyd K. Packer. Quoted in Salt Lake Tribune, September 20, 1993.
- Private Eye Weekly, Oct. 20, 1993. Quoted in Tanner and Tanner, "Mormon Inquisition?", 9.
- Bryan Waterman and Brian Kagel, The Lord's University: Freedom and Authority at BYU.
- David P. Wright, "In Plain Terms that We May Understand: Joseph Smith's Transformation of Hebrews in Alma 12-13" in Brent Metcalfe, ed., New Approaches to the Book of Mormon, 207.
|
418, 609n58
|
President Hinckley said "that all such enemies of the church deserve what they get as cursed servants of Satan." President Hinckley said:
"I think the Lord had them in mind when he declared: 'Cursed are all those that shall life up the heel against mine anointed, saith the Lord.'...[T]hey are the servants of sin, and are the children of disobedience themselves."
|
[ATTENTION!]Need missing portion of Hinckley quote. Who was he referring to?
|
- Gordon B. Hinckley, "Prophet Pre-eminently Grateful for Testimony," LDS Church News, April 8, 2000.
|
418, 609n59-60
|
The "Strengthening Church Members Committee" is a "pseudo-clandestine group to spy on Church members."
|
|
Peggy Fletcher Stack, "Feminist BYU Professor Fired, but Not Discredited," Salt Lake Tribune, June 8, 1996.
|
| Page
|
Claim
|
Response
|
Author's sources
|
422, n75
|
The Church acquired the Hofmann documents in order to suppress them.
|
|
- Jerald and Sandra Tanner, "Hofmann Talks," Salt Lake City Messenger (#64), January 1987, 7.
|
424
|
LDS officials "began hindering" the Hofmann investigation by "refusing to divulge information about the various transactions."
|
|
|
424
|
"Mormon leaders also blocked efforts by police to see exactly what documents were in LDS church vaults, apparently knowing that some of their authentic documents not yet released to the public might further damage the church's reputation if the contents of them were to be revealed."
|
|
- This is pure conjecture on the part of the author.
|
424, 610n77
|
According to the Tanners, Richard Turley's book Victims: The LDS Church and the Mark Hofmann Case "shows that Mormon Church leaders were engaged in a conspiracy of silence with regard to the McLellin collection to save the church's image."
|
|
- Jerald and Sandra Tanner, "Mormon Leaders suppress 'Key' Item in Murder Case," Salt Lake City Messenger (#83), November 1992, 3-4.
|
424, 610n78
|
LDS leaders "apparent lack of discernment with regard to Hofmann's legitimacy refuted in a most visible way the LDS belief that church leaders are divinely enabled by God to know deception when they see it."
|
|
- Bruce R. McConkie, Mormon Doctrine, 197.
- D&C 46:27
|
| Page
|
Claim
|
Response
|
Author's sources
|
434, 614n117-127
|
The belief that Latter-day Saints will "rescue the Constitution from ruin, and in so doing, ascend to a place of pre-eminence over America, and eventually the world" is "an integral part of Mormonism."
|
- No, actually it isn't—it isn't even discussed in Church.
|
- Joseph F. Smith, conference Report, October 1912, 11.
- Melvin J. Ballard, Conference Report, October 1928, 108.
- Mark E. Petersen, Conference Report, April 1946, 171.
- Joseph Fielding Smith, Conference REport, April 1950, 159.
- Harold B. Lee, Conference Report, October 1952, 18.
- Senator Wallace F. Bennett, BYU Speeches, February 15, 1961, 13.
- Dr. Ernest L. Wilinson, BYU speeches, April 21, 1966, 7.
- Ezra Taft Benson, "Jesus Christ-Gifts and Expectations," New Era, May 1975, 19.
- Ezra Taft Benson, Teaching of Ezra Taft Benson, 619.
- Daniel H. Ludlow, ed. Selections from Encyclopedia of Mormonism, "The Church and Society," 122.
- "Weatherman's politics cloud his role on TV," Seattle Times, November 24, 2000, 2.
|
