Difference between revisions of "Joseph Smith's reference library"

m (Miscellaneous)
m (Religious texts)
Line 45: Line 45:
 
=Religious texts=
 
=Religious texts=
 
* King James Bible - of this claim, at least, we are certain.  Though, whether Joseph had a Bible during the translation of the Book of Mormon is not clear. Substantial evidence suggests that he may not have. (See [[Book_of_Mormon_translation_method/Mainly_italics_altered#Option_.232:_Joseph_did_not_have_a_Bible|here]]).
 
* King James Bible - of this claim, at least, we are certain.  Though, whether Joseph had a Bible during the translation of the Book of Mormon is not clear. Substantial evidence suggests that he may not have. (See [[Book_of_Mormon_translation_method/Mainly_italics_altered#Option_.232:_Joseph_did_not_have_a_Bible|here]]).
 +
 +
=Romances=

Revision as of 20:59, 1 July 2009

Introduction

Critics who attempt a naturalistic explanation of Joseph Smith's production of the Book of Mormon often resort to claiming that Joseph gleaned a certain idea from a book or other source in his New England environment.

There is little or no evidence of Joseph having contact with such books, but this page attempts to lay out all the books which critics have suggested were in young Joseph's "reference library."

(If you add to thist list, please include a specific record to a specific critical work. Do not simply list works "off the top of your head" or by memory. We want this to be well-documented.)

Kabbalistic texts

Magical texts

Miscellaneous

Work Claim made Notes/remarks
  • E.T.A. Hoffmann, The Golden Pot [Der golden Topf]
  • John Milton's defense of polygamy
  • George D. Smith, Nauvoo Polygamy: "...but we called it celestial marriage" (Salt Lake City: Signature Books, 2008), 530-531. ( Index of claims , (Detailed book review))
  • George D. Smith, "Strange Bedfellows: Mormon Polygamy and Baptist History," Free Inquiry 16/2 (1996): 41-45; reprinted in Freedom of Conscience: Baptist/Humanist Dialogue, ed. Paul D. Simmons (Prometheus Books, 2000), 207-16, see footnote #69 at pp. 377-78.
  • N/A

Pamphlets and newspapers

Religious texts

  • King James Bible - of this claim, at least, we are certain. Though, whether Joseph had a Bible during the translation of the Book of Mormon is not clear. Substantial evidence suggests that he may not have. (See here).

Romances