FAIR is a non-profit organization dedicated to providing well-documented answers to criticisms of the doctrine, practice, and history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
Difference between revisions of "Book of Mormon/Textual changes/"Benjamin" changed to "Mosiah""
(→Endnotes: Rearranged) |
(→Endnotes: Rearranged) |
||
| Line 73: | Line 73: | ||
#{{note|1830BOM.200}}Book of Mormon, 1830 edition, p. 200. | #{{note|1830BOM.200}}Book of Mormon, 1830 edition, p. 200. | ||
#{{note|horton.249-250}}George A. Horton, Jr., "The Book of Mormon-Transmission from Translator to Printed Text," from ''The Book of Mormon: The Keystone Scripture'', edited by Paul R. Cheesman (Provo, Utah: BYU Religious Studies Center, 1988), pp. 249-250. | #{{note|horton.249-250}}George A. Horton, Jr., "The Book of Mormon-Transmission from Translator to Printed Text," from ''The Book of Mormon: The Keystone Scripture'', edited by Paul R. Cheesman (Provo, Utah: BYU Religious Studies Center, 1988), pp. 249-250. | ||
| + | #{{note|1830BOM.546}}Book of Mormon, 1830 edition, p. 546. | ||
#{{note|norwood.1}}L. Ara Norwood, [http://www.fairlds.org/FAIR_Conferences/2001_Benjamin_or_Mosiah.html#en8 Benjamin or Mosiah? Resolving an Anomaly in Mosiah 21:28] | #{{note|norwood.1}}L. Ara Norwood, [http://www.fairlds.org/FAIR_Conferences/2001_Benjamin_or_Mosiah.html#en8 Benjamin or Mosiah? Resolving an Anomaly in Mosiah 21:28] | ||
| − | |||
==Further reading== | ==Further reading== | ||
Revision as of 11:39, 24 August 2008
This article is a draft. FairMormon editors are currently editing it. We welcome your suggestions on improving the content.
| Answers portal |
| Book of Mormon |
|
 RESOURCES
|
|---|
|
General information: Book of Mormon & Bible: Criticisms: |
 PERSPECTIVES
|
 MEDIA
|
| OTHER PORTALS
|
Criticism
In the text currently found in Mosiah 21:28 of the Book of Mormon, the 1830 edition reads "Benjamin", while all subsequent editions read "Mosiah." Likewise, a reference to Benjamin in what is now Ether 4:1 was changed to "Mosiah" in 1849. Critics claim that "either God made a mistake when He inspired the record or Joseph made a mistake when he translated it."
Source(s) of the criticism
- John Ankerberg and John Weldon, Everything You Ever Wanted to Know About Mormonism (Eugene, Oregon: Harvest House, 1992), p. 310.
- Walter Martin, The Kingdom of the Cults (Minneapolis, Minnesota: Bethany House, 1985), p. 186.
- Jerald and Sandra Tanner, Mormonism-Shadow or Reality? (Salt Lake City: Modern Microfilm, 1972), p. 90.
- James White, Letters to a Mormon Elder (Southbridge, Massachusetts: Crowne, 1990), pp. 184-185.
Response
Could the Book of Mormon contain mistakes?
It should first be noted that the Book of Mormon itself does not claim to be free of errors. As Mormon himself stated in the introduction to the Book of Mormon:
- And now if there be fault, it be the mistake of men: wherefore condemn not the things of God, that ye may be found spotless at the judgment seat of Christ. (1830 Book of Mormon title page)
Mormon's son Moroni also acknowledges that the record that has been created is imperfect:
- And whoso receiveth this record, and shall not condemn it because of the imperfections which are in it, the same shall know of greater things than these. Behold, I am Moroni; and were it possible, I would make all things known unto you. Mormon 8꞉12
When Joseph Smith referred to the Book of Mormon as the "most correct book" on earth, he was referring to the principles that it teaches, not the accuracy of its textual structure.
What changes were made?
The first notable change is in what is now Mosiah 21:28:
1830 edition:
- And now Limhi was again filled with joy on learning from the mouth of Ammon that king Benjamin had a gift from God, whereby he could interpret such engravings; yea, and Ammon also did rejoice. [1] (emphasis added)
1837 edition:
- And now Limhi was again filled with joy on learning from the mouth of Ammon that king Mosiah had a gift from God, whereby he could interpret such engravings; yea, and Ammon also did rejoice. (emphasis added)
The change of the proper name "Benjamin" to "Mosiah" in what is now Mosiah 21:28 was made in the 1837 edition of the Book of Mormon by Joseph Smith. This change is present in all editions since that time. The change to Ether 4:1 was made in the 1849 edition, after the Prophet's death.[2]
The text of what is now Ether 4:1, which was an abridgment of the record of the Jaredites by Moroni, was changed in a similar manner:
1830 edition:
- ...and for this cause did king Benjamin keep them, that they should not come unto the world until after Christ should shew himself unto his people." [3](emphasis added)
1847 edition:
- ...and for this cause did king Mosiah keep them, that they should not come unto the world until after Christ should show himself unto his people. Ether 4꞉1(emphasis added)
The reason for both of these changes was never recorded.
The context of the event being described
The people of King Limhi were living under domination of the Lamanites, and had been separated for a number of years from the main body of the Nephites located in Zarahemla. Limhi's group sent out a "a small number of men" to search for the city of Zarahemla. These men became lost, but they did locate "a land which was covered with dry bones; yea, a land which had been peopled, and which had been destroyed." Amongst the ruins they located a record "engraven on plates of ore." Assuming this land to be the land of Zarahemla, the search party returned to report to Limhi, bringing the plates with them. Limhi did not have the ability to translate this record and was therefore unable to determine what was contained upon these plates.
Ammon, while on his mission to convert the Lamanites, encountered the people of Limhi "not many days" after the plates were obtained. The 1830 Book of Mormon reports that "Limhi was again filled with joy, on learning from the mouth of Ammon that King Benjamin had a gift from God, whereby he could interpret such engravings; yea, and Ammon did also rejoice."[4] However, a number of chapters prior to the description of this event, King Benjamin is reported to have died after turning over the kingship to his son Mosiah.
What does the Book of Mormon actually say about the event being discussed?
L. Ara Norwood notes that the Book of Mormon itself gives two parallel descriptions of the event.[5] One of these descriptions is found in Mosiah 8:13-14, which states:
- 13 Now Ammon said unto him: I can assuredly tell thee, O king, of a man that can translate the records; for he has wherewith that he can look, and translate all records that are of ancient date; and it is a gift from God. And the things are called interpreters, and no man can look in them except he be commanded, lest he should look for that he ought not and he should perish. And whosoever is commanded to look in them, the same is called seer.
- 14 And behold, the king of the people who are in the land of Zarahemla is the man that is commanded to do these things, and who has this high gift from God. Mosiah 8꞉13-14(emphasis added)
This appears to be a first-person account of what Ammon actually said to King Limhi. Note that Ammon refers to "the king of the people who are in the land of Zarahamla," without mentioning the name of that king. The other description is that found in Mosiah 21:25-28:
- 25 Now king Limhi had sent, previous to the coming of Ammon, a small number of men to bsearch for the land of Zarahemla; but they could not find it, and they were lost in the wilderness.
- 26 Nevertheless, they did find a land which had been peopled; yea, a land which was covered with dry bones; yea, a land which had been peopled and which had been destroyed; and they, having supposed it to be the land of Zarahemla, returned to the land of Nephi, having arrived in the borders of the land not many days before the coming of Ammon.
- 27 And they brought a record with them, even a record of the people whose bones they had found; and it was engraven on plates of ore.
- 28 And now Limhi was again filled with joy on learning from the mouth of Ammon that king Mosiah [changed from "Benjamin" as printed in the 1830 edition] had a gift from God, whereby he could interpret such engravings; yea, and Ammon also did rejoice. Mosiah 21꞉25-28 (emphasis added)
Note that this passage is written in the third person by Mormon, and does not quote the words of Ammon directly. This indicates the possibility that Mormon may have written the name "Benjamin" during his abridgment of the record.
Conclusion
Endnotes
- [note] Book of Mormon, 1830 edition, p. 200.
- [note] George A. Horton, Jr., "The Book of Mormon-Transmission from Translator to Printed Text," from The Book of Mormon: The Keystone Scripture, edited by Paul R. Cheesman (Provo, Utah: BYU Religious Studies Center, 1988), pp. 249-250.
- [note] Book of Mormon, 1830 edition, p. 546.
- [note] L. Ara Norwood, Benjamin or Mosiah? Resolving an Anomaly in Mosiah 21:28
Further reading
FAIR wiki articles
FAIR web site
- L. Ara Norwood, Benjamin or Mosiah? Resolving an Anomaly in Mosiah 21:28