![FairMormon Logo](https://www.fairlatterdaysaints.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/2021_fair_logo_primary.png)
FAIR is a non-profit organization dedicated to providing well-documented answers to criticisms of the doctrine, practice, and history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
m (→top: Bot replace {{FairMormon}} with {{Main Page}} and remove extra lines around {{Header}}) |
m |
||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{Main Page}} | {{Main Page}} | ||
{{Navigation:Latter-day Saint temples}} | {{Navigation:Latter-day Saint temples}} | ||
− | {{ | + | <onlyinclude> |
+ | {{H2 | ||
+ | |L=Actual_Page_name | ||
+ | |H=Display_page_name | ||
+ | |S= | ||
+ | |L1=Question: What is baptism for the dead? | ||
+ | |L2=Question: Are the dead being "baptized into the Mormon faith?" | ||
+ | |L3=Question: Is temple work a form of "ancestor worship"? | ||
+ | |L4=Source:Penrose:Improvement Era:Sept 1912:Baptism for the dead—How do we know which of our deceased relatives are to be baptized for | ||
+ | }} | ||
+ | </onlyinclude> | ||
{{:Question: What is baptism for the dead?}} | {{:Question: What is baptism for the dead?}} | ||
Line 8: | Line 18: | ||
{{:Source:Penrose:Improvement Era:Sept 1912:Baptism for the dead—How do we know which of our deceased relatives are to be baptized for}} | {{:Source:Penrose:Improvement Era:Sept 1912:Baptism for the dead—How do we know which of our deceased relatives are to be baptized for}} | ||
+ | |||
+ | {{Critical sources box:Latter-day Saint Temples/Baptism for the dead/Ancestor worship/CriticalSources}} | ||
{{endnotes sources}} | {{endnotes sources}} |
Baptism for the dead |
|
The temple endowment |
|
Temple sealings |
|
Other topics |
Jump to details:
Explained Elder G. Todd Christopherson:
Critics Jerald and Sandra Tanner claim that Church members' "obsession with the dead approaches very close to ancestral worship." In support of this, they quote Elder Adney Y. Komatsu, Assistant to the Council of the Twelve, Ensign May 1976, p.102. The critics wish to show that baptism for the dead is a form of "ancestor worship." In order to accomplish this, they extract phrases from a story told by Elder Komatsu about a couple that wished to be married, but were denied permission by the boy's parents. The use of genealogical research was the key that opened the door to allowing the couple to eventually be married. The authors carefully extract the phrases that they want to use, thereby making it impossible to see what Elder Komatsu was actually talking about. Baptism for the dead does not in any way represent "ancestor worship," and the authors had to search pretty hard to find a quote that they could butcher sufficiently to support this conclusion.
Reference | Original quote... | Mined quote... | Use of sources |
---|---|---|---|
The Changing World of Mormonism p. 517. "This obsession with the dead approaches very close to ancestral worship." | May I share with you this afternoon an experience that happened to a young couple who were members of the Church in Japan. They wished to be married, and as is the custom in Japan, they sought permission from their nonmember parents for the marriage to be performed. The boy’s parents refused to give permission. With concern and disappointment, the young couple prayerfully sought ways to fill their lives with meaningful Church activities and trusted that permission would be forthcoming later.
At this time Church members were planning a trip to the Hawaii Temple, and much emphasis was made and was being placed on the importance of genealogical research. So the couple joined with others in seeking out their ancestors and in planning to have the temple work done for them. The girl searched diligently through shrines, cemeteries, and government record offices, and was able to gather seventy-seven names. The boy’s uncle, who was a respected and influential member of the family, heard of this and was deeply impressed with and interested in her work. He noted the intense devotion of the girl to honoring her ancestors and suggested that such a young lady would be a good wife for his nephew. Permission was granted for the young people to be married, and the marriage was performed. Later they were sealed in the Hawaii Temple. It is a Japanese tradition that families gather together for special holidays in January and August. As this young couple joined their family members on these special occasions, they displayed their book of remembrance, and much interest was generated in their work and in the reasons for it. They discussed with those relatives assembled their ancestral lines and the importance of completing the genealogical research. It was difficult for their nonmember families to understand the reasons for a Christian church teaching principles such as “ancestral worship,” for this was a Buddhist teaching and tradition. Today many young men and women are completing their family group sheets and are teaching the gospel of Jesus Christ to their parents and their relatives by this method. Through genealogical research and through doing temple work for their progenitors, and especially with a temple now becoming available in Tokyo, members can so live that the gospel will yet be embraced by many more in the Orient. This great work has just begun. —Elder Adney Y. Komatsu, May 1976 |
May I share with you this afternoon an experience that happened to a young couple who were members of the Church in Japan.... the couple joined with others in seeking out their ancestors and in planning to have the temple work done for them. The girl searched diligently through shrines, cemeteries, and government record offices, and was able to gather seventy-seven names.... As this young couple joined their family members ... they displayed their book of remembrance.... They discussed with those relatives assembled their ancestral lines and the importance of completing the genealogical research. It was difficult for their nonmember families to understand the reasons for a Christian church teaching principles such as "ancestral worship," for this was a Buddhist teaching and tradition.... Through genealogical research and through doing temple work for their progenitors, and especially with a temple now becoming available in Tokyo, members can so live that the gospel will yet be embraced by many more in the Orient | Elder Adney Y. Komatsu, Assistant to the Council of the Twelve, Ensign May 1976, p.102 |
Charles W. Penrose, "Peculiar Questions Briefly Answered," Improvement Era Vol. 15, Num. 11 (September 1912):
Question 12: Baptism for the dead—How do we know which of our deceased relatives are to be baptized for, and how do we know when we are to be baptized for them?
Answer: If instead of "we" the questioner had used the word "you," we would answer: Often by personal revelation, always by the law of kindred and genealogy, and the direction of those divinely appointed to administer the ordinances commanded.[8]
Critical sources |
|
Notes
FAIR is a non-profit organization dedicated to providing well-documented answers to criticisms of the doctrine, practice, and history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
We are a volunteer organization. We invite you to give back.
Donate Now