FAIR is a non-profit organization dedicated to providing well-documented answers to criticisms of the doctrine, practice, and history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
Difference between revisions of "MormonFAQ/Church Discipline FAQ"
m |
m |
||
Line 97: | Line 97: | ||
{{FAQ | {{FAQ | ||
− | |q= | + | |q=What acts are not to be treated in a disciplinary council? |
− | |a= | + | |a=Leaders are instructed not to hold disciplinary councils for the following: |
+ | * Civil disputes | ||
+ | * Failure to live the Word of Wisdom | ||
+ | * Masturbation | ||
+ | * Pornography use | ||
+ | * Failure to pay tithing | ||
+ | * Failure to attend Church | ||
+ | * Failure to fulfill Church callings. | ||
+ | * Business failures or non-payment of debt (though felonious business practices might prompt a council as described above)<ref>''Handbook 1'', 6.7.1</ref> | ||
+ | |||
|quote= | |quote= | ||
|link= | |link= | ||
Line 111: | Line 120: | ||
{{FAQ | {{FAQ | ||
− | |q= | + | |q=Who decides to convene a disciplinary council? |
− | |a= | + | |a=Only bishops and stake or mission presidents may convene a disciplinary council. Bishops must have clearance from the stake president before initiating any council. |
|quote= | |quote= | ||
|link= | |link= | ||
Line 125: | Line 134: | ||
{{FAQ | {{FAQ | ||
− | |q= | + | |q=Where are disciplinary councils held? |
− | |a= | + | |a=Councils are usually held by the leaders of the geographic unit in which a member lives. If a member moves, a Church leader can place a “hold” on the transfer of records to another ecclesiastical unit. Leaders from the old and new unit then confer, and determine who is best suited to conduct the disciplinary council. |
|quote= | |quote= | ||
|link= | |link= | ||
Line 139: | Line 148: | ||
{{FAQ | {{FAQ | ||
− | |q= | + | |q=What determines if a council is handled by the bishop? When is the stake president involved? |
− | |a= | + | |a=The stake president is the president of the Church’s higher, or Melchizedek priesthood. Thus, any accusation against a priesthood holder must be resolved by the stake president. In practice, this means that experienced adult males tend to require stake disciplinary councils. Younger men who do not , teens, and women are typically managed by a bishop’s disciplinary council. |
|quote= | |quote= | ||
|link= | |link= | ||
Line 153: | Line 162: | ||
{{FAQ | {{FAQ | ||
− | |q= | + | |q=Who participates in a bishop’s disciplinary council? |
− | |a= | + | |a=The bishop’s disciplinary council consists of: |
+ | * The member accused of transgression | ||
+ | * The bishop | ||
+ | * The bishop’s two counselors | ||
+ | * A clerk or secretary to take minutes | ||
+ | Witnesses requested by either the bishop or the member for whom the council is convened may also attend. They will be present only to give evidence, and then will be excused. They do not participate in the rest of the council, and are not made aware of the decision reached. | ||
+ | |||
|quote= | |quote= | ||
|link= | |link= | ||
Line 165: | Line 180: | ||
|tag2= | |tag2= | ||
}} | }} | ||
+ | |||
{{FAQ | {{FAQ | ||
− | |q= | + | |q=Who participates in a stake disciplinary council? |
− | |a= | + | |a=The stake disciplinary council consists of: |
+ | *The member accused of transgression | ||
+ | *The stake president | ||
+ | *The stake president’s two counselors | ||
+ | *A clerk or secretary to take minutes | ||
+ | *Twelve members of the stake high council | ||
+ | Witnesses requested by either the bishop or the member for whom the council is convened may also attend. They will be present only to give evidence, and then will be excused. They do not participate in the rest of the council, and are not made aware of the decision reached. | ||
+ | |||
|quote= | |quote= | ||
|link= | |link= |
Revision as of 18:39, 12 June 2014
- REDIRECTTemplate:Test3
Answers portal |
Mormon FAQ |
RESOURCES |
---|
|
PERSPECTIVES |
MEDIA |
OTHER USEFUL SITES |
Contents
- 1 Frequently Asked Questions about Church Disciplinary Councils
- 1.1 Question: What is a “disciplinary council”?
- 1.2 A disciplinary council is a private meeting between Church leaders and a member that has either confessed or been accused of behavior which could threaten their right to full fellowship in the Church.
- 1.3 Question: How is a disciplinary council different from a “church court”?
- 1.4 “Church court” is an older terminology for the same thing.
- 1.5 Question: What behavior requires that a disciplinary council be held?
- 1.6 Disciplinary councils must be held for:
- Murder
- Incest
- Physical or sexual abuse of a child
- Apostasy
- Serious transgression by a prominent Church leader
- A pattern of serious transgression
- Transgression involving someone who is a predator and thus a danger to others[1]
- Felonies (e.g., attempted murder, rape, burglary, theft, robbery, perjury, fraud, sale of illicit drugs)
- Adultery, fornication, or homosexual conduct
- A serious transgression other than those which require a disciplinary council
- Abortion while a member of the Church (this includes paying for, submitting to, encouraging, or performing abortions)[2]
- Transsexual operation
- Civil disputes
- Failure to live the Word of Wisdom
- Masturbation
- Pornography use
- Failure to pay tithing
- Failure to attend Church
- Failure to fulfill Church callings.
- Business failures or non-payment of debt (though felonious business practices might prompt a council as described above)[3]
- The member accused of transgression
- The bishop
- The bishop’s two counselors
- A clerk or secretary to take minutes
- The member accused of transgression
- The stake president
- The stake president’s two counselors
- A clerk or secretary to take minutes
- Twelve members of the stake high council
Frequently Asked Questions about Church Disciplinary Councils
If you have a question about the whys, hows, or wherefores of Church Discipline in the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, our FAQ has the answer.
Question: What is a “disciplinary council”?
A disciplinary council is a private meeting between Church leaders and a member that has either confessed or been accused of behavior which could threaten their right to full fellowship in the Church.
Question: How is a disciplinary council different from a “church court”?
“Church court” is an older terminology for the same thing.
Question: What behavior requires that a disciplinary council be held?
Disciplinary councils must be held for:
- Murder
- Incest
- Physical or sexual abuse of a child
- Apostasy
A council must also always be held in the case of:
- Serious transgression by a prominent Church leader
- A pattern of serious transgression
- Transgression involving someone who is a predator and thus a danger to others[1]
Question: What constitutes “a serious transgression”?
A serious transgression is a “deliberate and major offense against morality.” The following are defined as “serious transgressions” for the purposes of determining whether disciplinary councils ought to be held, but the list is not exclusive:
- Felonies (e.g., attempted murder, rape, burglary, theft, robbery, perjury, fraud, sale of illicit drugs)
- Adultery, fornication, or homosexual conduct
Question: What behavior may require a disciplinary council?
Any of these may prompt a disciplinary council.
- A serious transgression other than those which require a disciplinary council
- Abortion while a member of the Church (this includes paying for, submitting to, encouraging, or performing abortions)[2]
- Transsexual operation
Question: What acts are not to be treated in a disciplinary council?
Leaders are instructed not to hold disciplinary councils for the following:
- Civil disputes
- Failure to live the Word of Wisdom
- Masturbation
- Pornography use
- Failure to pay tithing
- Failure to attend Church
- Failure to fulfill Church callings.
- Business failures or non-payment of debt (though felonious business practices might prompt a council as described above)[3]
Question: Who decides to convene a disciplinary council?
Only bishops and stake or mission presidents may convene a disciplinary council. Bishops must have clearance from the stake president before initiating any council.
Question: Where are disciplinary councils held?
Councils are usually held by the leaders of the geographic unit in which a member lives. If a member moves, a Church leader can place a “hold” on the transfer of records to another ecclesiastical unit. Leaders from the old and new unit then confer, and determine who is best suited to conduct the disciplinary council.
Question: What determines if a council is handled by the bishop? When is the stake president involved?
The stake president is the president of the Church’s higher, or Melchizedek priesthood. Thus, any accusation against a priesthood holder must be resolved by the stake president. In practice, this means that experienced adult males tend to require stake disciplinary councils. Younger men who do not , teens, and women are typically managed by a bishop’s disciplinary council.
Question: Who participates in a bishop’s disciplinary council?
The bishop’s disciplinary council consists of:
- The member accused of transgression
- The bishop
- The bishop’s two counselors
- A clerk or secretary to take minutes
Witnesses requested by either the bishop or the member for whom the council is convened may also attend. They will be present only to give evidence, and then will be excused. They do not participate in the rest of the council, and are not made aware of the decision reached.
Question: Who participates in a stake disciplinary council?
The stake disciplinary council consists of:
- The member accused of transgression
- The stake president
- The stake president’s two counselors
- A clerk or secretary to take minutes
- Twelve members of the stake high council
Witnesses requested by either the bishop or the member for whom the council is convened may also attend. They will be present only to give evidence, and then will be excused. They do not participate in the rest of the council, and are not made aware of the decision reached.
Question: ABC
123
Question: ABC
123
Question: ABC
123
Question: ABC
123
Question: ABC
123
Question: ABC
123
Question: ABC
123
Question: ABC
123
Question: ABC
123
|