Difference between revisions of "Mormonism and popular media/Dan Brown's next book and Mormonism"

(Response: Wikilink)
(rewrote article)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
==Issue==
 
==Issue==
There has been much speculation that the LDS Church will be featured in Dan Brown's next book.
+
There was much speculation that the LDS Church would be featured in the sequel to the ''The DaVinci Code''.
 
<!--
 
<!--
 
===Source(s) of the criticism===
 
===Source(s) of the criticism===
Line 6: Line 6:
  
 
==Response==
 
==Response==
There has been a great deal of speculation concerning Dan Brown's upcoming book, the sequel to ''The Da Vinci Code.'' The working title is ''The Solomon Key.''
+
On the dust-jacket of ''The DaVinci Code'' author Dan Brown provided a clue about the nature of his upcoming novel by crytically spelling out the phrase "Is there no help for the widow's son?" This is a phrase that is learned in every Masonic lodge when an initiate becomes a Master Mason. This clue pointed to the fact that Brown's new book would focus on Freemasonry.  
  
This speculation stems from the words of the Masonic Grand Hailing Sign of Distress that were hidden inside the fly leaf of ''The Da Vinci Code.'' By reading the words in bold print you will get the phase "Is there no hope for the widow's son?", a phase every [[Temple endowment and Freemasonry|Freemason]] learns as part of the ritual of the Master Mason degree.
+
When a Google search is performed on the phrase "Is there no help for the widow's son?" there are several page returns for a talk which was given in 1974 by Reed C. Durham at a meeting of the Mormon History Association. Since Durham's presentation spoke of Joseph Smith Jr. and the institution of Freemasonry some people drew the conclusion that perhaps Dan Brown's new literary work would deal, in a substantial way, with Mormons as well as Masons and it might make a connection between the two organizations.  
  
A [http://www.google.com/search?complete=1&hl=en&q=Is+there+no+hope+for+the+widow%27s+son&btnG=Google+Search Google search of this phase] returns several web pages about a speech by Reed C. Durham given at the 1974 meeting of the Mormon History Association. This speech, and the accompanying paper, outlined a connection between Joseph Smith, Jr. and the institution of Freemasonry.
+
It turned out that Dan Brown did refer to Mormonism in his fictional book called ''The Lost Symbol.'' The material appears in two short paragraphs within the book. Brown mentioned Joseph Smith by name, once. He referred to the translation of the golden plates of the Book of Mormon, once--utilizing the term 'magic eyeglasses' and putting forward a doubting opinion with regard to the reality of the translation 'miracle'. In addition, he used the erroneous phrase "baptism of the dead" (instead of "for" the dead), once. In both places where Joseph Smith and his ideology are mentioned they are being compared to other religious figures and practices.  
  
From this connection some people have concluded that Brown's forthcoming book will feature Mormonism in some sort of major role.
+
There are no connections forged in ''The Lost Symbol'' between Joseph Smith and the Masonic fraternity.  
 
 
Just how the phase "Is there no hope for the widow's son" became so connected with Joseph Smith, Jr. is an interesting topic. Joseph Smith was a Mason, as were most of the Latter-day Saint men of his time. When Joseph Smith was murdered by a mob at the jail in Carthage, Illinois, he called out "Oh Lord, my God!" as he fell from the jail house window. Dr. Durham proposed that [[Joseph Smith and the Masonic cry of distress|Joseph was giving the Masonic Grand Hailing Sign of Distress]], and it was from this event that he took the title of his now famous talk.
 
 
 
Dan Brown has given no indication that his upcoming book with have anything to do with the Latter-day Saints or the faith's complex connection to the Freemasons. Any Mason will tell you that Joseph Smith is far from the first or last Mason ever to have used the phase in time of need. Many accounts of its use in the Revolutionary and Civil Wars can be found in Masonic histories. Given that Brown himself has indicated that his next book takes place in Washington D.C., a city filled with Masonic symbolism in its building and even its city planning, it would seem unlikely that the LDS Church would play any role in such a title.
 
  
 
==Conclusion==
 
==Conclusion==
Dan Brown has given no indication of any connection between his forth coming book and the LDS Church. Such a connection is the result of speculation and nothing more.
+
Speculation about Mormonism's role in Dan Brown's latest book turned out to be unfounded.  
  
 
==Endnotes==
 
==Endnotes==

Revision as of 13:33, 17 September 2009

Issue

There was much speculation that the LDS Church would be featured in the sequel to the The DaVinci Code.

Response

On the dust-jacket of The DaVinci Code author Dan Brown provided a clue about the nature of his upcoming novel by crytically spelling out the phrase "Is there no help for the widow's son?" This is a phrase that is learned in every Masonic lodge when an initiate becomes a Master Mason. This clue pointed to the fact that Brown's new book would focus on Freemasonry.

When a Google search is performed on the phrase "Is there no help for the widow's son?" there are several page returns for a talk which was given in 1974 by Reed C. Durham at a meeting of the Mormon History Association. Since Durham's presentation spoke of Joseph Smith Jr. and the institution of Freemasonry some people drew the conclusion that perhaps Dan Brown's new literary work would deal, in a substantial way, with Mormons as well as Masons and it might make a connection between the two organizations.

It turned out that Dan Brown did refer to Mormonism in his fictional book called The Lost Symbol. The material appears in two short paragraphs within the book. Brown mentioned Joseph Smith by name, once. He referred to the translation of the golden plates of the Book of Mormon, once--utilizing the term 'magic eyeglasses' and putting forward a doubting opinion with regard to the reality of the translation 'miracle'. In addition, he used the erroneous phrase "baptism of the dead" (instead of "for" the dead), once. In both places where Joseph Smith and his ideology are mentioned they are being compared to other religious figures and practices.

There are no connections forged in The Lost Symbol between Joseph Smith and the Masonic fraternity.

Conclusion

Speculation about Mormonism's role in Dan Brown's latest book turned out to be unfounded.

Endnotes

Further reading

FAIR wiki articles