FAIR is a non-profit organization dedicated to providing well-documented answers to criticisms of the doctrine, practice, and history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
Difference between revisions of "Book of Mormon/Anachronisms/Shiz struggles to breathe"
m (→Response) |
(Brain graphics added; DRAFT tag removed) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| − | |||
==Criticism== | ==Criticism== | ||
| + | [[Image:Brain_1.gif|frame|Right|The human brain. The midbrain is located at the level marked 'cerebral peduncle'. From: Henry Gray, ''Anatomy of the Human Body'', 1918, Fig 677. [http://www.bartleby.com/107/illus677.html].]] | ||
| + | |||
In [http://scriptures.lds.org/ether/15/31#31 Ether 15:31], a final showdown occurs between two warriors, Shiz and Coriantumr. Coriantumr "smote off the head of Shiz...[and] after he had smitten off the head...Shiz raised up on his hands and fell; and after that he had struggled for breath, he died." | In [http://scriptures.lds.org/ether/15/31#31 Ether 15:31], a final showdown occurs between two warriors, Shiz and Coriantumr. Coriantumr "smote off the head of Shiz...[and] after he had smitten off the head...Shiz raised up on his hands and fell; and after that he had struggled for breath, he died." | ||
| Line 6: | Line 7: | ||
===Source(s) of the Criticism=== | ===Source(s) of the Criticism=== | ||
| + | |||
*John R. Farkas and David A. Reed, ''Mormonism: Changes, Contradictions, and Errors,'' (Grand Rapids, Mich. : Baker Books, 1995), 152. | *John R. Farkas and David A. Reed, ''Mormonism: Changes, Contradictions, and Errors,'' (Grand Rapids, Mich. : Baker Books, 1995), 152. | ||
*Ed Decker, ''Decker's Complete Handbook on Mormonism'' (Eugene: Harvest House, 1995), 114. | *Ed Decker, ''Decker's Complete Handbook on Mormonism'' (Eugene: Harvest House, 1995), 114. | ||
*Latayne Colvett Scott, ''The Mormon Mirage : a former Mormon tells why she left the church'' (Grand Rapids : Zondervan Pub. House, 1979), 90. | *Latayne Colvett Scott, ''The Mormon Mirage : a former Mormon tells why she left the church'' (Grand Rapids : Zondervan Pub. House, 1979), 90. | ||
| + | |||
| + | [[Image:mesencephalon_1.gif|frame|right|Closeup of mid- and hind-brain; the mid-brain is the area above the pons. From: Henry Gray, ''Anatomy of the Human Body'', 1918, Fig 681. [http://www.bartleby.com/107/illus681.html].]] | ||
==Response== | ==Response== | ||
| − | |||
Contrary to the critics' assumptions, | Contrary to the critics' assumptions, | ||
| Line 21: | Line 24: | ||
==Conclusion== | ==Conclusion== | ||
| − | With the death scene of Shiz, Joseph Smith provides the reader with a vivid example of a catastrophic injury which is consistent with a weary, sloppy cut made by the exhausted Coriantumr. It is a realistic touch, | + | With the death scene of Shiz, Joseph Smith provides the reader with a vivid example of a catastrophic injury which is consistent with a weary, sloppy cut made by the exhausted Coriantumr. It is a realistic touch, and a phenomenon that went unrecognized in the medical literature of the modern era until 1898. |
==Further reading== | ==Further reading== | ||
Revision as of 18:51, 20 October 2005
Contents
Criticism
The human brain. The midbrain is located at the level marked 'cerebral peduncle'. From: Henry Gray, Anatomy of the Human Body, 1918, Fig 677. [1].
In Ether 15:31, a final showdown occurs between two warriors, Shiz and Coriantumr. Coriantumr "smote off the head of Shiz...[and] after he had smitten off the head...Shiz raised up on his hands and fell; and after that he had struggled for breath, he died."
Critics insist that this would not, or could not, happen.
Source(s) of the Criticism
- John R. Farkas and David A. Reed, Mormonism: Changes, Contradictions, and Errors, (Grand Rapids, Mich. : Baker Books, 1995), 152.
- Ed Decker, Decker's Complete Handbook on Mormonism (Eugene: Harvest House, 1995), 114.
- Latayne Colvett Scott, The Mormon Mirage : a former Mormon tells why she left the church (Grand Rapids : Zondervan Pub. House, 1979), 90.
Closeup of mid- and hind-brain; the mid-brain is the area above the pons. From: Henry Gray, Anatomy of the Human Body, 1918, Fig 681. [2].
Response
Contrary to the critics' assumptions,
- Shiz's death struggle illustrates the classic reflex posture that occurs in both humans and animals when the upper brain stem (midbrain/mesencephalon) is disconnected from the brain. The extensor muscles of the arms and legs contract, and this reflex action could cause Shiz to raise up on his hands [Hadfield, 324].
Cutting the brainstem in this location causes the muscles which extend (straighten) the arms and legs to contract. This makes the arms and legs rigid, which would raise a corpse up until lack of oxygen and blood loss caused eventual muscle failure.
Conclusion
With the death scene of Shiz, Joseph Smith provides the reader with a vivid example of a catastrophic injury which is consistent with a weary, sloppy cut made by the exhausted Coriantumr. It is a realistic touch, and a phenomenon that went unrecognized in the medical literature of the modern era until 1898.
Further reading
FAIR wiki articles
Book of Mormon/Anachronisms/Shiz struggles to breathe
FAIR web site
- FAIR Topical Guide:
External links
- John W. Welch, in "The 'Decapitation' of Shiz," Insights (November 1994): 2. [3]
Printed material
- M. Gary Hadfield, "Neuropathology and the Scriptures," BYU Studies 33:2 (1993): 313-28. [4]