FAIR is a non-profit organization dedicated to providing well-documented answers to criticisms of the doctrine, practice, and history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
Difference between revisions of "Book of Abraham facsimiles/Facsimile 2"
(m) |
(m) |
||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
{{Resource Title|Book of Abraham Facsimile 2: The hypocephalus}} | {{Resource Title|Book of Abraham Facsimile 2: The hypocephalus}} | ||
{{draft}} | {{draft}} | ||
| − | {{ | + | == == |
| + | {{Criticism label}} | ||
| − | The illustration represented by Facsimile 2 ([http://scriptures.lds.org/en/abr/fac_2 view]) is a ''hypocephalus'', a disc made of linen, papyrus, or bronze, covered with inscriptions and images which relate to one of the last spells in the Book of the Dead. The disc was placed under the head (''hypocephalus'' = Greek: "under the head") of the deceased in the belief that the spell would cause the head and body to be enveloped in flames or radiance, making the deceased divine. | + | The illustration represented by Facsimile 2 ([http://scriptures.lds.org/en/abr/fac_2 view]) is a ''hypocephalus'', a disc made of linen, papyrus, or bronze, covered with inscriptions and images which relate to one of the last spells in the Book of the Dead. The disc was placed under the head (''hypocephalus'' = Greek: "under the head") of the deceased in the belief that the spell would cause the head and body to be enveloped in flames or radiance, making the deceased divine. Joseph Smith's notes to Facsimile 2 identify several figures as representing God sitting in the heavens among the stars and others of his creations. |
| − | Joseph Smith's | + | Criticisms related to Facsimile 2 are related to Joseph Smith's explanations of the individual elements. |
| − | = | + | == == |
| − | {{ | + | {{Topics label}} |
| + | {{SummaryItem | ||
| + | |link=Book of Abraham/Astronomy/Kolob-Sun | ||
| + | |subject=Relationship between Kolob and the Sun | ||
| + | |summary=The Book of Abraham states that “the sun [is said] to borrow its light from Kolob through the medium of Kae-e-vanrash, which is the grand Key, or, in other words, the governing power (Abraham Fac 2,Fig 5),” while astrophysics has shown that “The Sun shines ... because of thermonuclear fusion. It does not get its light from any other star.” | ||
| + | }} | ||
| + | {{SummaryItem | ||
| + | |link=Book of Abraham/Astronomy/Revolution Time | ||
| + | |subject=Revolution Time | ||
| + | |summary=Critics of Mormonism claim that "LDS doctrine regarding astronomy is permeated with references to time being measured, or 'reckoned' according to a star's or planet's rate of rotation. Furthermore, this 'reckoning of time' is a prime distinguisher in terms of 'greatness.' From the standpoint of modern cosmology, this makes no sense at all. Rates of rotation are largely arbitrary, and of little comment or concern from a fundamental point of view." | ||
| + | |||
| + | == == | ||
| + | {{Response label}} | ||
| − | ===Facsimile 2 was | + | ===Facsimile 2 was missing portions and was "restored" before publication=== |
Regarding Facsimile 2, it should be noted that portions of the original Facsimile 2 appear to have been missing, and that the missing portions were filled in with characters or images taken from other sources before the image was published in the ''Times and Seasons''. Some material was copied from the Joseph Smith papyri. Among the missing sections may have been the area identified as section #3, which matches a figure which appears on Joseph Smith Papyrus IV. One interesting thing about this restoration is that the figure in the bark boat actually does appear in this section of at least one other hypocephalus. | Regarding Facsimile 2, it should be noted that portions of the original Facsimile 2 appear to have been missing, and that the missing portions were filled in with characters or images taken from other sources before the image was published in the ''Times and Seasons''. Some material was copied from the Joseph Smith papyri. Among the missing sections may have been the area identified as section #3, which matches a figure which appears on Joseph Smith Papyrus IV. One interesting thing about this restoration is that the figure in the bark boat actually does appear in this section of at least one other hypocephalus. | ||
}} | }} | ||
| − | [[File:Hypocephalus.split.3D.1.jpg| | + | [[File:Hypocephalus.split.3D.1.jpg|200 px|thumb|right]] |
| − | [[File:Hawk-headed.god.Re.in.Joseph.Smith.Papyri.jpg| | + | [[File:Hawk-headed.god.Re.in.Joseph.Smith.Papyri.jpg|200 px|thumb|right]] |
===Joseph Smith correctly identified some elements of Facsimile 2=== | ===Joseph Smith correctly identified some elements of Facsimile 2=== | ||
| − | + | One critic of Mormonism states, "The following is a side-by-side comparison of what Joseph Smith translated in Facsimile #2 versus what it actually says according to Egyptologists and modern Egyptology." The letter displays a graphic from "mormoninfographics.com" called "The Book of Abraham - Hypocephalus, a funerary amulet," which compares Joseph Smith's interpretations of elements of Facsimile 2 with those provided by Egyptologists. Although this is an anti-Mormon source, the graphic acknowledges that Joseph may have gotten an element correct: "there is some agreement." | |
}} | }} | ||
| − | [[File:Mormoninfographic.facsimile2.sons.of.horus.jpg| | + | [[File:Mormoninfographic.facsimile2.sons.of.horus.jpg|200 px|right]] |
Revision as of 19:27, 10 April 2014
- REDIRECTTemplate:Test3
Book of Abraham Facsimile 2: The hypocephalus
This article is a draft. FairMormon editors are currently editing it. We welcome your suggestions on improving the content.
Questions
The illustration represented by Facsimile 2 (view) is a hypocephalus, a disc made of linen, papyrus, or bronze, covered with inscriptions and images which relate to one of the last spells in the Book of the Dead. The disc was placed under the head (hypocephalus = Greek: "under the head") of the deceased in the belief that the spell would cause the head and body to be enveloped in flames or radiance, making the deceased divine. Joseph Smith's notes to Facsimile 2 identify several figures as representing God sitting in the heavens among the stars and others of his creations.
Criticisms related to Facsimile 2 are related to Joseph Smith's explanations of the individual elements.
Topics
Relationship between Kolob and the Sun
Summary: The Book of Abraham states that “the sun [is said] to borrow its light from Kolob through the medium of Kae-e-vanrash, which is the grand Key, or, in other words, the governing power (Abraham Fac 2,Fig 5),” while astrophysics has shown that “The Sun shines ... because of thermonuclear fusion. It does not get its light from any other star.”Revolution Time
Summary: Critics of Mormonism claim that "LDS doctrine regarding astronomy is permeated with references to time being measured, or 'reckoned' according to a star's or planet's rate of rotation. Furthermore, this 'reckoning of time' is a prime distinguisher in terms of 'greatness.' From the standpoint of modern cosmology, this makes no sense at all. Rates of rotation are largely arbitrary, and of little comment or concern from a fundamental point of view."Detailed Analysis
Facsimile 2 was missing portions and was "restored" before publication
Regarding Facsimile 2, it should be noted that portions of the original Facsimile 2 appear to have been missing, and that the missing portions were filled in with characters or images taken from other sources before the image was published in the Times and Seasons. Some material was copied from the Joseph Smith papyri. Among the missing sections may have been the area identified as section #3, which matches a figure which appears on Joseph Smith Papyrus IV. One interesting thing about this restoration is that the figure in the bark boat actually does appear in this section of at least one other hypocephalus.
Joseph Smith correctly identified some elements of Facsimile 2
One critic of Mormonism states, "The following is a side-by-side comparison of what Joseph Smith translated in Facsimile #2 versus what it actually says according to Egyptologists and modern Egyptology." The letter displays a graphic from "mormoninfographics.com" called "The Book of Abraham - Hypocephalus, a funerary amulet," which compares Joseph Smith's interpretations of elements of Facsimile 2 with those provided by Egyptologists. Although this is an anti-Mormon source, the graphic acknowledges that Joseph may have gotten an element correct: "there is some agreement." }}
