FAIR is a non-profit organization dedicated to providing well-documented answers to criticisms of the doctrine, practice, and history of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
FAIR Resources for Come, Follow Me – Restoration Scripture
Week 4: January 20–26 “The Hearts of the Children Shall Turn to Their Fathers”
Doctrine and Covenants 2; Joseph Smith- history 1:27-65
Doctrinal Focus
- Key doctrines addressed in this week’s reading
The Restoration of Priesthood Keys
Elijah’s mission to restore priesthood keys is central to temple work.
- Elijah’s role, as prophesied in Malachi 4:5–6, was to turn the hearts of the children to the fathers and vice versa, bridging generational gaps through sacred temple ordinances. This mission fulfills God’s promise to unite families eternally, ensuring that no soul is left behind in the work of salvation.
The power of the priesthood binds families eternally.
- Doctrine and Covenants 2 emphasizes that the priesthood enables the sealing of families across generations, creating eternal connections. Through temple work, the blessings of the priesthood extend beyond mortality, fulfilling God’s plan for the salvation and exaltation of His children.
Divine Preparation Through Trials
God prepared Joseph Smith through years of instruction and waiting.
- Moroni’s repeated visits over four years were not just for instruction but also to instill patience and humility in Joseph. This period of preparation ensured that Joseph was spiritually mature and ready to bear the responsibility of restoring the gospel and translating the Book of Mormon.
Personal trials can refine us for divine purposes.
- Joseph’s struggles with persecution, poverty, and self-doubt helped him develop a deeper reliance on God. These experiences illustrate how trials often serve as a refining process, equipping us with the strength and faith needed to fulfill our divine potential.
The Mission of the Book of Mormon
The Book of Mormon is central to the Restoration.
- Moroni emphasized that The Book of Mormon was prepared by God to restore truths lost through centuries of apostasy. Its purpose is not only to testify of Christ but also to fulfill prophecies about the gathering of Israel and the preparation for Christ’s Second Coming.
God provides tools to accomplish His work.
- The process of translating the Book of Mormon demonstrates God’s guidance through tangible and spiritual means.
- Joseph Smith used both the Urim and Thummim and a seer stone during the translation, which were sacred instruments enabling him to receive revelation and articulate the ancient script in a comprehensible way.
- The combination of these tools underscores how God empowers His servants with divine resources tailored to their missions. These instruments, understood as aids to revelation, illustrate that God works within the understanding and capacities of His chosen servants to fulfill His purposes.
Historical & Contextual Insights
- Insights in this week’s study
Setting
- The events occurred in Manchester, New York, in 1823, three years after Joseph’s First Vision.
- This was a time of widespread religious revivalism and fervor in the region, often called the “Burned-over District.”
- Amid this environment, Joseph faced intense persecution and personal challenges, especially because of his testimony of seeing God and Jesus Christ.
Context
- Moroni’s visits were part of God’s plan to prepare Joseph to restore the gospel and translate the Book of Mormon. These repeated visits over a span of four years not only provided specific instructions but also reinforced Joseph’s understanding of his divine calling. The angel’s messages drew on ancient prophecies, connecting Joseph’s work to the fulfillment of scripture and the gathering of Israel.
Significance
- Understanding this context reveals how God calls and prepares imperfect people for great work. Joseph’s experience shows that divine preparation often requires patience, faith, and obedience over time.
- Despite his youth and imperfections, Joseph was entrusted with a pivotal role in restoring sacred truths to the earth, highlighting God’s ability to magnify His chosen servants.
Takeaway
- By learning of Joseph’s perseverance, we recognize that personal struggles can refine us for divine missions. His story reminds us that feelings of inadequacy or past mistakes do not disqualify us from being instruments in God’s hands.
- Instead, they can strengthen our reliance on Him and help us grow into the people He knows we can become.
The Role of Elijah
- Elijah’s mission fulfilled the prophecy in Malachi, inaugurating the work of family history and temple ordinances. His restoration of the priesthood keys enabled the sealing power that binds families eternally, creating connections across generations.
- Without this sacred work, the earth would be “utterly wasted” at Christ’s coming, as the eternal family unit is essential to God’s plan.
- This underscores the eternal significance of sealing families and provides a tangible way for individuals to participate in the gathering of Israel through temple work and family history research.
Historical and Cultural Context of Seer Stones
Doctrine and Covenants 1:24 says:
“Behold, I am God and have spoken it; these commandments are of me, and were given unto my servants in their weakness, after the manner of their language, that they might come to understanding.”
This verse provides a profound insight into how God communicates with His children, meeting them in their cultural and intellectual context to convey divine truths effectively. This principle applies to the use of the seer stone during the translation of the Book of Mormon.
Historical and Cultural Context of Seer Stones
In Joseph Smith’s time, the use of seer stones or divining rods was not uncommon, especially in rural areas where folk traditions and beliefs about spiritual gifts were part of the culture. These practices were often tied to a broader belief in divine interaction in everyday life. Individuals believed that certain objects could help them discern hidden truths or find lost items, and this was viewed by many as a spiritual gift.
Joseph’s own community likely saw his use of a seer stone as consistent with such practices. In fact, his early use of a seer stone for tasks like locating water or treasure would have been recognized by his contemporaries as part of a broader spiritual tradition rather than something extraordinary or controversial.
- For more information on this subject, watch this podcast:
Me, My Shelf, & I – Episode 3 – Seer Stones: Post-Biblical Folk Magic
Theological Insight
- The use of the seer stone in translating the Book of Mormon can be seen as an extension of the principle taught in D&C 1:24. God used tools and methods familiar to Joseph and his cultural milieu, allowing Joseph to focus on receiving and transmitting divine revelation without being distracted by unfamiliar processes.
- This approach highlights God’s accommodation of human limitations and cultural contexts in His dealings with His children.
Connection to Biblical and Modern Precedents
The Bible also refers to divinely sanctioned instruments for revelation, such as the Urim and Thummim used by ancient Israelite priests to discern God’s will (Exodus 28:30).
Similarly, in Joseph’s time, divining rods and seer stones were seen by many as modern analogues to these ancient tools.
Example: Oliver Cowdery’s use of a divining rod was initially considered a spiritual gift (D&C 8:6–8), showing that the Lord acknowledged and adapted these cultural practices to accomplish His purposes.
"Speaking in their language"
It is very plausible that God’s use of the seer stone reflects His principle of speaking to His children “in their language.”
By utilizing a familiar tool, He demonstrated His willingness to work within the cultural and spiritual framework of Joseph’s time to reveal His eternal truths.
This underscores the broader theme of divine accommodation—God meeting His children where they are and elevating them to higher understanding through their own experiences and context.
If you have questions on this week’s reading, please email your questions to us here.
Apologetic Application
Criticism 1: Joseph Smith invented the story of Moroni’s visits.
- Claim: Joseph fabricated Moroni’s visit and the gold plates to gain attention.
Response:
Historical evidence:
Joseph Smith’s account of Moroni’s visits remained consistent over time, even as he faced widespread skepticism and persecution. His detailed descriptions of Moroni, the gold plates, and their purpose in restoring the gospel align across multiple retellings, including early accounts written in his own lifetime. Furthermore, the broader historical context, including the religious fervor of the Second Great Awakening, supports the plausibility of divine intervention to restore truth during this period.Eyewitness support:
Key witnesses, including Martin Harris, Oliver Cowdery, and David Whitmer, provided consistent and unwavering testimonies that they saw and handled the gold plates. These witnesses endured significant hardship and even estrangement from Joseph, yet they never recanted their statements. Their corroboration lends credibility to Joseph’s account and demonstrates that the story was not simply his fabrication.Spiritual confirmation:
Countless individuals, both during Joseph’s time and today, have prayed and received spiritual witnesses of the truth of the Book of Mormon. This widespread spiritual confirmation reflects the fulfillment of Moroni’s promise (Moroni 10:4–5) and serves as evidence that Joseph’s claims were not mere inventions but divine truths meant to be shared with the world.Logical analysis of claim:
Joseph endured intense persecution, financial difficulties, and personal sacrifice as a result of his prophetic calling, which is inconsistent with fabricating a story for attention or gain. Logical reasoning suggests that someone seeking personal benefit would have abandoned their claims under such adversity. Instead, Joseph persisted in his testimony, further reinforcing the authenticity of his experiences.
Criticism 2: Joseph Smith plagiarized the Book of Mormon from other sources.
- Claim: Joseph drew from sources like the View of the Hebrews, the King James Bible, or other contemporary texts to create the Book of Mormon.
Response:
Historical evidence:
Extensive studies have been conducted comparing the View of the Hebrews and other alleged sources with the Book of Mormon, revealing significant differences in structure and narrative. (You can compare it for yourself; you can read View of the Hebrews in its entirety on BYU’s Religious Studies Center website.)The Book of Mormon’s complexity, with its interwoven narratives, internal consistency, and unique doctrinal themes, far exceeds the content of any supposed source. Additionally, Joseph’s limited education and resources make the scope of the Book of Mormon an unlikely product of his own intellect.
Eyewitness support:
Witnesses like Oliver Cowdery, David Whitmer, and Emma Smith attested that Joseph dictated the text with no notes or manuscripts, often resuming mid-thought without backtracking or revising previous sections. Emma specifically stated that Joseph could not have written such a complex text on his own, underscoring the miraculous nature of the translation process.Spiritual confirmation:
Millions of people worldwide have gained a testimony of the Book of Mormon through personal study and prayer, in fulfillment of Moroni’s promise. This widespread spiritual witness provides evidence beyond textual analysis, affirming that the Book of Mormon is divinely inspired and not a product of plagiarism.Logical analysis of claim:
If Joseph had plagiarized the Book of Mormon, he would likely have used sources that were widely known and accepted at the time to gain credibility.Instead, the Book of Mormon introduces new and challenging doctrines, unique narratives, and a profound testimony of Christ that would have been difficult to fabricate or borrow without detection.
Criticism 3: Joseph Smith was a treasure seeker and used deceptive practices.
- Claim: Joseph’s use of a seer stone and involvement in treasure digging discredit his prophetic role.
- Response:
Historical evidence:
Treasure seeking and the use of seer stones were common practices in Joseph’s time, especially in rural communities like upstate New York.Joseph’s early use of a seer stone was not hidden or shameful in that context and was seen as part of a broader belief in divine gifts. His transition from treasure seeking to translating scripture reflects a divine redirection of his spiritual gifts for a higher purpose.
Eyewitness support:
Numerous individuals, including Martin Harris and Emma Smith, testified of the sacredness of the translation process, noting that Joseph used the seer stone under divine direction. This transformation in the use of the stone aligns with the biblical precedent of God repurposing common practices (e.g., Moses’ rod or the Urim and Thummim) for His work.Spiritual confirmation:
The divine results of Joseph’s work, including the Book of Mormon and the Restoration of the gospel, testify of God’s power to use imperfect tools and individuals to accomplish His purposes. The fruits of Joseph’s mission affirm his prophetic role, regardless of his earlier activities.Logical analysis of claim:
If Joseph were merely a charlatan using treasure seeking as a facade, it would be illogical for him to claim visions and undertake the monumental task of restoring a church amidst constant persecution. His willingness to endure hardship and sacrifice for his testimony suggests authenticity rather than deception.
Criticism 4: Joseph Smith’s First Vision is inconsistent across accounts.
- Claim: Variations in Joseph’s accounts of the First Vision indicate that he fabricated or exaggerated the story.
Response:
Historical evidence:
The differences in Joseph’s accounts reflect the natural variation that occurs when recounting a deeply personal experience to different audiences over time. Scholars and historians note that the core elements of the vision—Joseph seeing God and Jesus Christ, and receiving instruction—are consistent across all versions. The variations enrich our understanding by providing additional context and insights.Eyewitness support:
Joseph shared the First Vision with family, friends, and church members who supported and believed his account, many of whom joined him in the Restoration despite opposition. Their belief in his testimony adds credibility to his sincerity and consistency over time.Spiritual confirmation:
Countless members of the Church have felt the Spirit while studying the First Vision, confirming its truth and its role in God’s work. This spiritual witness transcends potential concerns about minor differences in wording or detail.Logical analysis of claim:
A fabricated story would likely be carefully crafted and unchanging to avoid scrutiny. The personal and varied nature of Joseph’s accounts is consistent with genuine human memory and the challenges of describing a profound spiritual event over time.
Practical Applications
Practical solutions for someone in faith crisis:
Focus on Personal Revelation
Action Step: Pray to know your “standing before God.”
Why it helps:
- Personal revelation serves as a direct line of communication with God, allowing you to receive His guidance and love tailored to your unique circumstances. When doubts or feelings of inadequacy arise, personal revelation helps confirm your divine worth and reinforces your faith in God’s plan for you.
- By seeking this connection, you deepen your relationship with Heavenly Father and build spiritual resilience, making it easier to face life’s challenges with confidence and peace.
How to do it:
- – Set aside time for quiet reflection and prayer, ensuring an environment free from distractions.
- – Begin your prayer by expressing gratitude to God for blessings and insights you’ve already received.
- – Ask sincerely for understanding of your relationship with Him and what He would have you do to grow closer to Him.
- – Record impressions, feelings, and any thoughts that come to your mind during or after prayer.
- – Study scriptures related to your questions and ponder their application in your life.
Encouraging Thought: “Please remember tomorrow, and all the days after that, that the Lord blesses those who want to improve, who accept the need for commandments and try to keep them, who cherish Christlike virtues and strive to the best of their ability to acquire them. If you stumble in that pursuit, so does everyone; the Savior is there to help you keep going. If you fall, summon His strength.” (Elder Jeffrey R. Holland, Tomorrow the Lord Will Do Wonders among You)
Elder Holland’s words remind us that our worth to God isn’t contingent on flawless performance but on our willingness to try, repent, and keep progressing.
As you pray and seek personal revelation, remember that God rejoices in every step you take toward Him, no matter how small it may seem. He is patient and loving, guiding you as a tender parent encourages a child, always celebrating growth over perfection.
Engage in Family History Work
Action Step: Begin or continue researching your family history and participate in temple ordinances for your ancestors.
Why it helps:
- Family history work connects us to our ancestors and fulfills the promise of turning our hearts to our fathers (D&C 2:2). This work helps us feel the Spirit, deepen our understanding of God’s eternal plan, and experience joy in uniting families across generations.
- Engaging in this sacred work also reminds us that we are part of a divine family with a shared purpose, strengthening our sense of identity and belonging.
How to do it:
- – Create or update your FamilySearch.org account.
- – Search for missing connections in your family tree and verify historical records.
- – Share family stories or photos with your family members to build connections.
- – Prepare names for temple ordinances and make a plan to attend the temple regularly.
Encouraging Thought:
“When we gather our family histories and go to the temple on behalf of our ancestors, God fulfills many of these promised blessings simultaneously on both sides of the veil. Similarly, we are blessed when we help others in our wards and stakes do the same.” (Elder Dale G. Renlund, Family History and Temple Work: Sealing and Healing).
As you take these steps, trust that you are part of something eternal, with blessings that ripple through your family and beyond.
Study and Apply Ancient Prophecies
- Action Step:
Identify one prophecy referenced by Moroni (e.g., Malachi 4:5–6, Isaiah 11, Joel 2) and study its meaning and fulfillment in the context of the Restoration.
Why it helps:
- Understanding how ancient prophecies are fulfilled in modern times strengthens faith in God’s plan and provides assurance that He is actively guiding His children. This knowledge offers a deeper appreciation for the Restoration, the role of the Book of Mormon, and your place in God’s work.
- Applying these lessons in your own life helps you recognize how God’s promises are still being fulfilled today.
How to do it:
- – Choose a prophecy referenced in Joseph Smith—History 1:36–41.
- – Use Church resources like the Gospel Library app or study manuals to understand its historical and doctrinal significance.
- – Reflect on how the prophecy connects to your personal life or to modern events in the Church.
- – Share insights with family members, friends, or your class to deepen understanding collectively.
Encouraging Thought:
“Surely the Lord God will do nothing, but he revealeth his secret unto his servants the prophets” (Amos 3:7). Studying fulfilled prophecies assures us that God’s promises are sure, and just as He fulfilled ancient promises, He will fulfill those He has made to us individually.
This assurance allows us to face the future with faith and confidence in His divine timing.
Ideas for Teaching
Hearts Turned to the Temple
Objective: Help learners see the importance of Elijah’s mission in temple work.
Materials Needed:
- – Family photos or a FamilySearch account.
Activity Steps:
- – Introduction (5 minutes): Discuss the purpose of temples using pictures or stories.
- – Scripture Discussion (5 minutes): Read Doctrine and Covenants 2:1–3 aloud and discuss the phrase “turn the hearts.”
- – Application (5 minutes): Share ways to engage in family history and temple work.
Follow-Up Question: How has temple work blessed your family?
Prepared Through the Refiner’s Fire
Objective: Teach about divine preparation through trials.
Materials Needed:
- – Timeline of Joseph Smith’s early life.
Activity Steps:
- – Introduction (5 minutes): Present a timeline showing significant events in Joseph’s early life.
- – Scripture Discussion (5 minutes): Read Joseph Smith—History 1:27–33 and discuss how trials refined Joseph.
- – Application (5 minutes): Ask learners to reflect on how challenges have prepared them for personal growth.
Follow-Up Question:How can trials strengthen our trust in God?
Obedience on Sacred Ground
Objective: Highlight the importance of obedience to divine commands.
Materials Needed:
- – Visual of the Hill Cumorah.
Activity Steps:
- – Introduction (5 minutes): Show a picture of the Hill Cumorah and discuss its significance.
- – Scripture Discussion (5 minutes): Read Joseph Smith—History 1:50–53.
- – Application (5 minutes): Discuss the importance of obeying God’s timing and instructions.
Follow-Up Question: How can we align our will with God’s?
QUICK REFERENCE
Key Points
- – Elijah’s mission ensures eternal family connections.
- – Joseph’s preparation highlights God’s patience in teaching His servants.
- – The Book of Mormon fulfills ancient prophecies.
Core Apologetic Answers
Why was Elijah’s return necessary? (D&C 2:1–3—To restore keys for temple work.)
How do Joseph’s accounts strengthen faith? (Consistent narratives over time support his prophetic role.)
Key Resources
Scriptures
- Doctrine and Covenants 2: This revelation contains the prophecy about Elijah’s mission to restore the sealing keys, which is foundational for temple work and family history. It emphasizes the eternal nature of families and the work required to unite them.
- Joseph Smith—History 1:27–65: These verses provide a firsthand account of Moroni’s visits to Joseph Smith, the instructions he received, and the challenges he faced in preparing for his divine mission. This narrative reinforces faith in God’s preparatory work for the Restoration.
Church Documents
- Saints, Volume 1, Chapter 3 “Plates of Gold“: This chapter offers a detailed historical narrative of Joseph Smith’s early experiences, including his encounters with Moroni and the discovery of the gold plates. It provides context for understanding the challenges and significance of these events in the Restoration.
- General Handbook: “God’s Plan and Your Role in His Work of Salvation and Exaltation”: This section outlines the Church’s divinely appointed responsibilities, including living the gospel, caring for others, and uniting families through temple ordinances. It connects modern members’ roles to the foundational principles revealed in these scripture blocks.
Online Resources
- FamilySearch.org/discovery: This tool allows individuals to explore and contribute to family history, turning hearts to their ancestors and participating in temple work. It provides practical ways to apply the teachings of Doctrine and Covenants 2.
- Elder Stevenson’s talk, “Simply Beautiful—Beautifully Simple”: This General Conference address emphasizes the simplicity and power of living the gospel, inviting others to Christ, and participating in temple work. It aligns beautifully with the themes of restoration and family unity in this lesson.
Footer
